Winter Tires vs All-Weather Tires

Need help? Call us at 416-847-7343.

Winter tires, all-weather tires, all-season tires. The names sound similar but they are not the same, and the difference matters for safety and the law. TireSet.ca ships free to all Canadian provinces with Affirm at checkout. Here is what separates them.

Winter Tires

Dedicated winter tires use the softest cold-weather rubber and the most aggressive snow-and-ice tread, delivering the shortest braking distances when it is cold and snowy. They wear quickly in warm weather, so you swap them off in spring. They always carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol.

All-Weather Tires

All-weather tires are the middle ground. They carry the same 3PMSF winter symbol, so they are legal winter tires including in Quebec, but they also handle summer heat, so you can run them year round and skip the seasonal swap. They give up some peak winter grip versus a dedicated winter tire, but for milder winters they are an excellent one-tire solution.

Do Not Confuse These with All-Season Tires

All-season tires are a different thing. Despite the name they are really three-season tires: usually only M+S rated, not 3PMSF, their rubber hardens below 7 degrees Celsius, and they are not legal for winter in Quebec. For year-round tires that are truly winter capable, look for the mountain snowflake symbol and choose all-weather, not all-season.

Pay over time with Affirm

Choose Affirm at checkout to split your purchase into monthly payments. Subject to eligibility and approval.

FINANCING OPTIONS | Available at Checkout
As low as 0% APR with Affirm, subject to eligibility and approval.

More Winter Tire Guides

Winter Tires vs All-Weather Tires FAQ

What is the difference between winter and all-weather tires?

Winter tires use the softest cold-weather compound for the best hard-winter grip but must be swapped off in spring. All-weather tires carry the 3PMSF winter symbol and stay on year round, trading some peak winter grip for convenience.

Are all-weather tires legal in Quebec?

Yes, if they carry the three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) symbol. All-season tires with only an M+S rating do not qualify for Quebec's winter tire law.

Should I buy winter or all-weather tires?

If you face heavy snow, ice, or a long hard winter, dedicated winter tires are safest. If your winters are milder and you would rather not swap twice a year, 3PMSF all-weather tires are a solid compromise.